The 10 Best Jamaican Patty Spots in the GTA That Absolutely Slap

Victoria Pfeifer
7 days ago
4 min read

Golden pastries filled with spicy meat, crumbled on parchment. Vibrant yellow crust, scattered thyme sprigs, rustic and appetizing.

If you've ever burned your tongue because you couldn’t wait for your patty to cool, you’re in the right place. Jamaican patties aren’t just a snack, they’re a Toronto rite of passage. Golden, flaky crusts packed with seasoned beef, chicken, or veggies, usually tucked into a warm, pillowy slice of coco bread, it's affordable, it's fast, and when done right, it’s straight-up addictive. The GTA is home to some of the best patty spots outside Jamaica, so we’re ranking the 10 best that consistently bring the heat.

1. Allan’s Pastry Shop – Scarborough & North York

Hands holding a half-wrapped yellow patty in a white paper bag. Person wears a blue sweater. Small anchor tattoo visible on finger. — Photo by Allan's Pastry Shop

Allan’s is that spot. If you're from Scarborough, you probably grew up on these patties. The beef here has the perfect level of spice, not trying too hard, just bold, savory flavor that hits the back of your throat in the best way. The crust is flaky and golden without being too dry, and their coco bread? Soft, fresh, and perfect for turning one patty into a full meal. There’s usually a line, but it's fast-moving and worth every minute. No matter how many places pop up, Allan’s holds its ground as a Scarborough legend.

2. Fahmee Bakery – Scarborough

Stack of meat-filled pastries on a plate in front of a bakery. The sign reads "Fahmee Bakery, Jamaican Foods." Warm, sunny setting. — Photo by Fahmee Bakery

Fahmee’s patties are so good that they made it into grocery stores and convenience shops all across Ontario, but don’t let that mass distribution fool you. The real magic happens at the original Scarborough location, where you can get them piping hot and fresh. The beef is juicy with a slow-building spice, and their jerk chicken patty is an absolute sleeper hit. Plus, the crust has a perfect balance of crunch and chew. If you’ve only tried Fahmee’s frozen patties, do yourself a favor and experience the real deal.

3. Caribbean Queen of Patties – Bloor West Village

Hand holding a wrapped patty in front of a Caribbean restaurant with a yellow sign. Text includes "Caribbean Queen Patties," and menu items. — Photo by Caribbean Queen of Patties

This tiny shop near High Park might look unassuming, but it packs a serious punch. Caribbean Queen has been serving up homemade-style patties for decades and is beloved by locals and loyalists across the city. Their patties are soft, flaky, and filled to the edges with rich, flavorful filling. You can taste the difference; these aren’t mass-produced. Their veggie patty is especially impressive, offering actual vegetables, not just mystery mush. You’ll usually catch the owner chatting it up behind the counter, keeping it friendly and community-driven.

4. Patty Time – Scarborough

Hand holding a half-eaten golden pastry filled with a savory, crumbled mixture. Background is blurred and dark, adding contrast. — Photo by BlogTO

Patty Time has been a Scarborough institution for over 30 years, and they’re still going strong. The patties are bigger than average and packed with spicy, well-seasoned meat that makes each bite a full experience. What sets them apart is their specialty fillings, curry goat, anyone? Yes, it exists, and yes, it’s fire. Patty Time feels like your cousin’s basement kitchen that turned into a successful business. It’s comfort food wrapped in flaky pastry.

5. Tinnel’s Patties – Multiple Locations

Golden-brown baked pastries with crimped edges in a clear plastic bag. They're stacked neatly, displaying a crispy texture. — Photo by Tinnel’s Patties

Tinnel’s is one of the most widely recognized patty brands in the GTA, and for good reason. Whether you’re grabbing one from a Mississauga plaza or a downtown deli fridge, the flavor and texture rarely miss. Their crust is iconic, more golden and slightly puffier than most, and their spicy beef brings a consistent heat that doesn’t overpower. While you can find Tinnel’s patties in stores, nothing beats walking into their bakery and grabbing one fresh with a cold Ting on the side. It’s the definition of a classic done right.

6. CRUMBS GOURMET PATTIES - Kensington Market

meat and cheese jamaican patty — Photo by CRUMBS GOURMET PATTIES

CRUMBS brings high-end creativity to the humble patty, serving up croissant-style crusts and rich, juicy fillings in the heart of Kensington Market. Each patty is handmade daily by owner Pierre, with standout options like spicy beef stuffed with cheddar or their viral pizza patty remix. It’s a bit bougie price-wise, but the quality and flavor hit hard; this isn’t your average grab-and-go patty.

7. Randy’s Take-Out – Dufferin & Eglinton

Stack of three cut pastries on a wooden board, showing different fillings. Bright, flaky crusts with a blurred indoor background. — Photo by Randy's

If there’s a line out the door, you’re probably at Randy’s. This Oakwood-Vaughan staple has been holding it down for decades and still brings the heat. Their spicy beef patty is practically legendary, and while the crust is a bit thicker than some, it holds the moisture perfectly. These patties are built to satisfy. You can grab one solo or level up with coco bread and a D&G soda. Randy’s is the blueprint for what a classic Toronto patty shop should be: no-frills, all flavor, and deeply rooted in the community.

8. Golden Krust – North York

Golden-brown pastry on a wooden surface, partially wrapped in Golden Krust packaging. A green drink bottle is in the background.

Okay, hear us out. Yes, it’s a franchise. But Golden Krust does what many chains can’t: deliver consistency. Their patties have a slightly different flavor profile, more buttery, less spicy, but still bring comfort food energy. Think American-Jamaican fusion, and you’ll get it. Great for those new to patties or looking for something a little milder. The beef and cheese combo is their best seller, and honestly? It hits when you're craving something fast, filling, and satisfying without sacrificing quality.

Final Puff

The Jamaican patty is more than just a food item; it’s a piece of Toronto’s cultural identity. Whether you’re posted up in Scarborough, mobbing through Mississauga, or discovering a gem in Brampton, these eight spots prove that Caribbean flavor is alive and thriving across the GTA. So skip the drive-thru and pull up to one of these patty legends instead. And don’t come for us if we missed your favorite, unless you’re bringing receipts and patties.